Some random notes on a Mennonite history conference

How I ended up at “Long-Distance Relationships: Communication and the Mennonite Diaspora,” a conference hosted by the Centre for Transnational Mennonite Studies in Winnipeg, Oct. 23-24, 2026: Way, way back — in June 2000 to be exact — I heard history professor Gerald Friesen share some interesting ideas concerning time and space and communication transitions as a model for looking at Canadian history. Any history, in fact. This excited me, especially ways communications media and the dynamic of immigration might intersect. I ended up doing my MA thesis on the discourse of, and communication in, the Zionsbote, an early Mennonite periodical, between 1884 and 1906.

I’m long out of the academic world, but when I noticed that communication was the theme of this year’s conference, I got excited again, thinking it might be my last kick at the can for this sort of thing, so why not submit a proposal? I cast about for something. Ah, my grandparents’ letters! More than 140 of them, between 1913 and 1918. Love letters. Grandfather Heinrich Harder was in the forestry service in Russia, and then, without a break, sent to the Caucasus front during the First World War, and grandmother Helena Derksen was at home with her parents in Fischau, Molotschna Colony, Russia (today’s Ukraine). He proposed by letter, she eventually said Yes by letter. I analyzed the correspondence in the context of the war, in the context of courtship customs of the time, and in terms of words-on-paper versus face-to-face.

An opening keynote address and 27 presentations (15 minutes each): Steven Nolt of Elizabethtown College gave the keynote. The title of his address was “‘A Phone Is as Righteous as Its Owner’: Old Order and ‘Plain” Mennonites Navigate Digital Communication and the Internet.” As the title suggests, Nolt went through various Old Order groups to show their allowings around media, and their resistances. I was struck by one of the principles he found in his research: “Human limitation is not a problem to be conquered.”

Interestingly, just this morning I heard writer Zadie Smith, in an interview by Matt Galloway on CBC, say, in response to his question what it means to be human, “To be human is an acknowledgement of limits.” Life has limits, she went on to say, and the techbros, the AI world, have no conception of that, don’t think there should be limits.

There were quite a few papers on letters: Benjamin Eby’s letters to other ministers, women’s “epistolary labour” in Fürstenland, letters across the Iron Curtain, the courtship letters mentioned above, and the challenge of navigating KGB interference in letter writing. There were also papers on radio, newsletters, cassette tapes (audio letters), and travelogue accounts in the Rundschau.

Re cassettes: since my husband and I used to exchange cassette conversations with his family in Paraguay, especially with one of the sisters, I felt briefly rueful during the presentation and discussion about cassette communication, for I recently got rid of the remaining tapes in my possession. Were they of historical interest? I don’t think so. Would my children listen to them? I didn’t think so. If I was wrong about that, it’s too late now.

Newspapers/periodicals: Saturday contained two sessions of four papers each on Mennonite newspapers/periodicals and how they’ve linked Mennonites, how they’ve created what Benedict Anderson called “imagined community.” I really enjoyed these, as I agreed so thoroughly on their role in creating belonging for their reading community, having myself worked at a Mennonite periodical for some years.

Rosemary Vogt, in “Early Formation of Networked Belonging” asked “Why would a people committed to standing apart build such sophisticated systems for staying connected?” She spoke further of the claim that belonging is produced, not just expressed.

The thing is, we don’t just want to stay connected, but historical circumstances like migration and exile and missionary work have scattered Mennonites all over the world.

I was super proud of our niece Caroline Dueck de Klassen, archivist at Colony Fernheim, Paraguay, and her presentation on the first five years of the Mennoblatt. Mennonites had barely settled in the Chaco before beginning, under the leadership of Nikolai Siemens, a newspaper which connected people within Fernheim but also represented the fledgling settlement to the larger world.

In 1933-34, in what was called the Neufeld debate, colonists discussed that representation in the Mennoblatt. It was not about the fact that Fernheim struggled, she said, for that was definitely a fact, but how, and how much of, that struggle should be communicated.

Another amazing paper: Die Mennonitische Post, in its 50 years, has been a vital connector for the scattered colonies (across the Americas) of so-called Low German Mennonites. Until recently, former editor Kennert Giesbrecht said, it was “maybe the only growing printed newspaper.” It has always carefully structured and adapted itself to the particular needs of its reading community.

Speaking of Low German, historian and author Andrei Fast of Kazachkstan, who doesn’t speak English, presented his entire paper, “A Century of Separation, Silence, and Reunion: The Story of the Fast Famiy between Canada and the Soviet Union” in the Low German language. Is this a first, I wonder? Fortunately, for those who don’t understand Low German, or understand it poorly as I do, slides with his content translated into English were projected on to the wall.

It was a genuinely interesting conference, with a variety of communication angles, many more than I can elaborate here. Like the connection between Mennonites and Tolstoy, for example, and a policeman’s story of “Communication, Policing, and the Arrival of Dietsche Migrants in Southern Alberta”. And topics of women’s suffering or sex/gender or the environment in Mennonite newspapers/periodicals; the Mennonite Centre in Molochansk; Canadian Jewish Archives; Canadian Mennonites and the Screen Arts. And so on, and more.

Communication continues to change. Several times in the past, I attended conferences like this and reported on them for Mennonite magazines. When those magazine reports came out, it was hoped that people who couldn’t attend would get at least a glimpse into what had transpired. Now such pressure to report, in any kind of comprehensive way, is lifted. I can be personal and random. 🙂 People were able to attend by livestream, and anyone curious about any of the papers can watch both days of presentations on YouTube. I think that’s a good thing.

On the road with Sweet Bobby

I left Tsawwassen close to 7 this morning and now, 7 in the evening, I’ve got my legs stretched out on a bed in a room at the Shimmerhorn Inn in Creston. Nothing luxurious but it’s a bed and the place is rather pretty in blue and white, and I’m very grateful indeed to have the first day of my road trip to Winnipeg behind me. I plan to attend a Mennonite history conference, visit some friends and relatives, and then double back through Saskatchewan for a week’s writing retreat at St. Peter’s Abbey in Muenster. More about all that later if I find time and energy to keep up a bit of a blog-diary.

IMG_2413

I decided to take the #3 out of B.C. On the map that highway  looks like an earthworm wiggling along the border. No end of curves, that’s for sure, and no end either of up and down, but it’s magnificent country in so many ways, the mountains and trees and valleys and rivers, and in Keremeos and Osoyoos, vineyards and orchards and bustling fruit markets. Traffic was relatively light and road conditions were good.

IMG_2412

Before setting out, I downloaded several books and podcasts to help the hours along. Today I listened to the last four episodes of a six-episode podcast I’d started at home called Sweet Bobby. It’s a harrowing true tale about some complicated catfishing, which is not, I learned, the action of catching catfish but “a deceptive activity in which a person creates a fictional persona or fake identity on a social networking service, usually targeting a specific victim.”

Here’s the description of the series.

Kirat is a successful radio presenter. On Facebook she meets Bobby, a handsome cardiologist. He’s a catch. Soon, they get tangled up in a love affair full of lies and manipulation. Then… Kirat discovers a deception of almost unimaginable proportions.

I like podcasts that tell a true story, and are journalistic in style. (Recommendations welcome.) I also listened to an hour of Writers & Co. Although Eleanor Wachtel, one of the best interviewers ever, has just retired after 33 years of doing the show, some of her favourites are being aired throughout the summer.

Day one nearly done then. My body still feels like it’s in motion, but I’ll go for a walk and then, hopefully sleep well, and be ready to drive again tomorrow. A few more mountains to get over or around.

Besa: The Promise

H. and I saw a remarkable documentary at Canadian Mennonite University last evening. Besa: The Promise told a story I’d not known, of Muslims in Albania taking in and saving Jews during World War II. It seemed unexpected, surprising actually, that this would have happened–Muslims and Jews are enemies, aren’t they?–and the more inspiring because of it.

BessaRescreenBesa refers to an Albanian honor code: one opens the door to a knock, one offers safety to refugees, one keeps one’s word. Several stories played within the larger story: the narrative of the German invasion and hunt for Jews with commentary from elderly survivors and their Muslim hosts; a Jewish photographer’s quest to honor via portraits the Albanians who’d responded so nobly and at great danger to themselves in those evil times; and most compellingly, a Muslim man’s attempt to fulfill a promise made between his late father and his wartime Jewish guest. Since I hope others will see the film, I won’t say more about that particular promise. Continue reading →